Statements and Quantifiers

Definitions

Mathematical Statements and Negation

Statement

Definition

A sentence that has a definite state of being true or false

Negation

Definition

Suppose is a statement. Then the negation of , denoted by , is the statement asserting the opposite truth value to .

Ie, the double negation of is logically equivalent to

Quantifier and Quantified Statements

Open Sentence

Definition

A sentence that contains a variable, where the truth of the sentence is determined by the value of the variable chosen from the domain of the variable

Quantified Statement

Definition

  1. A universally quantified statement is of the form

- Read as "For all in , is true"
2. An existentially quantified statement is of the form

- Read as "There exists (at least one) value of in for which is true"

Negation of Quantifiers

Definition

Quantified Statement Negation

Nested Quantifiers

Important - Order matters

Where is false, is true.

Important - Domain matters

where is true (), is false.

Scope of Quantifiers

Info

Quantifiers will cover the entire scope they are in

Example

Proofs

Proof Method - Contradiction

Definition

Let be a statement. Note that either or must be false, so the compound statement is always false.

Example

  • " is true" is a contradiction
  • is always false

Tautology

The opposite of a contradiction is a tautology.

Definition

An assertion that is true in every interpretation

Example

  • is always true
  • is always true

Proving Universally Quantified Statements

Proof Method - Direct Proof

Proof

To prove chose a representative mathematical object . This cannot be a specific object. It has to be a placeholder. Then, show that P must be true for , using known facts about

Remark

case analysis can be used for different parts of the domain

Proof Method - Constructive Proof

Proof

To prove , start from and show the steps to arrive to the desired result.

Remark

Constructive proofs provide a method for creating the desired object. Usually, direct proofs are constructive proofs.

Proof Method - Counter-Example

Proof

To disprove , find an element for which is false.

Proving Existentially Quantified Statements

Proof Method - Example

Proof

To prove the , provide an explicit value of from the domain that satisfies

Proof Method - Uniqueness

Proof

  1. Existence: prove that there is at least one element such that is true (i.e prove )
  2. Uniqueness: do one of the following
    1. Assume and are true for , and prove that this assumption leads to the conclusion
    2. Assume and are true for distinct (so ), and prove that this assumption leads to a contradiction

Proof Method - Negate

Proof

To prove the existentially quantified statement , prove the universally quantified statement